This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

A child's constant "why" is often a real search for answers, and watching it can teach adults to look at the world again with an open mind. The fitrah is the innate disposition Allah created every person upon, and our own reflection, offered with care, is that the openness of a young child is one place where we can glimpse that original nature.

The Prophet ﷺ said that every child is born on the fitrah, rendered in this translation as a true faith of Islam (Abu Huraira, Sahih al-Bukhari 1385). And Allah says He brought us out of our mothers' wombs "not knowing a thing" and gave us hearing, vision and hearts (Qur'an 16:78).

IN SHORT

Researchers who studied preschoolers' everyday questions found many of them were genuine requests for information, repeated when no answer came. In a small experiment, four-year-olds who were allowed to ask questions solved a hidden-object puzzle more often. In adults, a brain-imaging study linked curiosity to better memory. Tafakkur, reflection on what Allah has made, is the adult practice of this openness, and it can be practised at any age. These links between research and the fitrah are our own reflection, offered with care.

Two ways to meet an ordinary thing: the shrug that stops at because it is, and the question that keeps looking until an answer comes

The car has not left the driveway when the questions start in the back seat. Why is the moon out when it's still light? Why does the bus have a door at the back? Why do the traffic lights take turns?

The driver answers the first two. By the fifth the answers are getting shorter, and somewhere around the tenth the driver is hoping for a red light.

It is easy to hear all of this as noise. Research on how children ask gives the noise a purpose.

What is the fitrah in Islam?

The fitrah is the natural, inborn disposition Allah created people upon, and the Qur'an and Sunnah both name it. Allah tells us to turn our faces to the religion, "inclining to truth", and to hold to "the fiṭrah of Allāh upon which He has created [all] people" (Qur'an 30:30).

The hadith about the child says it from the other side:

THE HADITH

"Every child is born with a true faith of Islam ..."

The hadith speaks about faith and about how a child's surroundings shape the path. It says nothing about curiosity as such, and we want to keep that line clear.

What we offer as our own reflection is smaller. If a child arrives with an inner leaning toward truth, then the way a young child looks at the world, with wide attention, endless questions and little pretence, is a place where we can watch a wide openness at work. It can remind a grown person of what it felt like to be curious about everything.

Children are not saints. The fitrah describes where we start, and a child still needs guidance on the way.

Why do young children ask so many questions?

Young children ask so many questions because questions work: they are an efficient way to get the information a child needs at the moment she needs it. This is the central idea of a long research monograph on the subject.1

The author worked through several sets of data. The first analysed every question asked by four children in recorded conversations, between about one and five years old. The children asked many information-seeking questions and got informative answers. When an answer did not come, they asked again, which suggests the goal was the information itself.

The questions also grew up with the children. Their content followed what they were working out about the world at each age.

A fourth study in the same monograph put the idea to a test. Sixty-seven four-year-olds had to work out which of two objects was hidden in a box. Half were allowed to ask questions. Those children were significantly more likely to identify the object. They were just as likely to ask about things they could not see, such as "does it purr?", as about colour, though colour was the quicker route.

The honest limits: the home recordings came from only four children, and the experiment tested one kind of puzzle. This is a careful study of how young children ask. It cannot predict what any one child will become.

What is tafakkur in Islam?

Tafakkur is reflection: turning over what Allah has made, slowly enough that the familiar becomes a sign again. The Qur'an praises those who remember Allah in every posture and "give thought to the creation of the heavens and the earth" (Qur'an 3:191).

It can be the adult, deliberate form of that openness. Allah made hearing, vision and hearts for us so that we might be grateful. A newborn has these tools and not much else. A child with a question is using them at full stretch.

Many adults close the question early. A streetlight is a streetlight, and "why" gets replaced by a shrug. Tafakkur reopens it. Why does that streetlight come on at just that moment? Who set the light fading at that hour?

Does it matter whether we reopen it? One line of research suggests it does. In a brain-imaging study of adults, people remembered answers better when they had been curious about the question, and they remembered it again a day later. Memory for unrelated material seen while curious was also better. Activity rose in reward-related areas of the brain.2

The study was a lab experiment with adults, so it shows a link between curiosity and memory. It cannot show that cultivating curiosity changes a life, and one study is a starting point.

What about the honesty and innocence we see in children?

A young child often says exactly what she sees. The soup is too hot, the guest's hat is funny, the story is boring. It can be awkward, and it can be refreshing, because very little sits between what the child notices and what the child says.

This is an observation from ordinary life, and there is no study behind it here. Children also learn to bend the truth as they grow, and teaching a child adab, including when and how to say a thing, is part of raising her well.

What we can take from the observation is smaller and more useful. Adults often notice a feeling or a doubt and then talk themselves out of looking at it. A child has not learned to do that yet. Watching a child hold a doubt up to the light and keep looking can be a gentle model for how to be honest with ourselves.

How do we relearn it by watching a child?

We relearn it by letting the child lead and paying attention to what she pays attention to. These steps are our own suggestions, drawn from the research above, and none of them is a ruling.

  1. Let the child lead the play. Ten minutes where she chooses the game, the rules and the order of the toys. The adult's job is to follow and to notice.

  2. Answer the first why, then ask one back. "Why do you think the moon is out?" The research suggests children use questions to build their understanding, so handing the question back keeps that going.

  3. Stay with one small thing a little longer. A beetle on the path, the way a puddle moves. The adult may find that it holds attention for longer than expected.

  4. With no child nearby, borrow the posture. Pick one ordinary thing in view, ask why it is the way it is, and keep looking until some kind of answer arrives. Looking it up counts.

None of this replaces the obligations of the day. It fits between them: in the car, at the table, in the ten minutes after Asr.

Frequently asked questions

What is the fitrah in Islam?

The fitrah is the natural disposition Allah created people upon. The Qur'an tells us to hold to "the fiṭrah of Allāh upon which He has created [all] people" (Qur'an 30:30), and the Prophet ﷺ taught that every child is born on it (Abu Huraira, Sahih al-Bukhari 1385).

Why do young children ask so many questions?

Because questions are an efficient way to get needed information. In one study of four children's recorded conversations, the children asked many information-seeking questions and kept asking when no answer came.1 The sample was small.

What is tafakkur in Islam?

Tafakkur is reflection on what Allah has made, the kind praised in the Qur'an for those who "give thought to the creation of the heavens and the earth" (Qur'an 3:191). A child's endless why can be a small, untrained version of it.

Can adults get their curiosity back?

Adults can practise it. In a brain-imaging study, adults remembered answers better when they were curious about the question.2 It is a small study, and a practice like asking "why" about one ordinary thing a day is a gentle place to begin.

How do we let a child lead play?

Offer ten minutes where the child chooses the game and the rules, follow her lead, and notice what holds her attention. This is our own suggestion, and any amount of time helps.

Sources

Research and references

  1. Chouinard MM. (2007). Children's questions: a mechanism for cognitive development. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 72(1), vii-126.

  2. Gruber MJ, Gelman BD, Ranganath C. (2014). States of curiosity modulate hippocampus-dependent learning via the dopaminergic circuit. Neuron 84(2), 486-496.