This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

When someone's flaw irritates us far more than it should, it is worth asking whether the same trait lives somewhere in us, unlooked at. The idea has a name, Carl Jung's "shadow", and it gives us a gentle way to take a first honest look, with Allah's forgiveness close at hand.

The Qur'an says the soul was inspired with discernment of both its wickedness and its righteousness (Qur'an 91:8), and that whoever purifies it has succeeded.

IN SHORT

Psychology has long suspected that we notice in others the qualities we deny in ourselves, though the evidence is limited and debated. One careful set of experiments supports a version of it. The Qur'an adds that the soul was given discernment of both its wrong and its right, and that the one who purifies it has succeeded. We can bring that work to Allah, asking forgiveness.

Two ways to meet an irritation: judge the other person and move on, or ask where it lives in us and ask Allah's forgiveness

A cousin tells the same story at every gathering, the one where he is the hero, and a jaw tightens at the far end of the table. By the drive home the irritation has grown into a speech. We can recite his faults in order.

Then a quieter thought arrives, uninvited. When did we last tell a story so that the room would look at us?

We push it away, because the cousin is easier to look at.

What is the shadow self?

The shadow self is the part of ourselves that we refuse to look at, so it works on us from the dark. The Swiss psychiatrist Carl Jung used "the shadow" for the traits a person disowns because they don't fit the picture they want to present.

Jung's claim, put plainly, is that what we won't face in ourselves doesn't disappear. It resurfaces in our reactions, often as a sharp irritation at someone who carries the same trait in plain view. Psychologists call the mechanism projection.

We hold this as a lens, a way of noticing. Jung's wider system is a theory and remains unsettled science. Where it helps, it helps because it asks one honest question.

Does the research back it up?

Partly, and with limits. In 1997, the psychologists Leonard Newman, Kimberley Duff and Roy Baumeister opened a paper by noting that the idea of defensive projection is old, and that the evidence for it was "limited and controversial".1 They proposed a mechanism. When people try hard not to think about an unwanted trait in themselves, the trait becomes easy for the mind to reach, and the mind then uses it to read other people's behavior.

Their first four studies found that people who avoid thinking about a threatening trait and also deny having it more readily inferred that trait from others' behavior. The last two studies gave experimental support: people who were asked or predisposed not to think about a trait in themselves later projected it onto someone else.1

That is a result worth holding gently. It is one model, tested in a lab, and it does not say that every irritation is a hidden confession.

A second finding is broader. A review by Emily Pronin, Thomas Gilovich and Lee Ross gathered evidence that people see others as more susceptible to bias than themselves, and described a blind spot about our own.2 We are not well placed to audit ourselves, which is the case for asking the question slowly and honestly, and for asking it more than once.

What does the Qur'an say about the part of us we don't want to see?

The Qur'an says the soul was inspired with discernment of both its wickedness and its righteousness:

THE QUR'AN

"And inspired it [with discernment of] its wickedness and its righteousness,"

The oath continues, in the verses that follow:

THE QUR'AN

"He has succeeded who purifies it, And he has failed who instills it [with corruption]."

Read slowly, the verses name two things: a soul given discernment of wrong and right, and success for the one who purifies it.

Jung and the Qur'an speak in different vocabularies, and we don't claim the verse proves his theory. The verse says the soul was given discernment of both. Whether it speaks to what irritates us is our own reading, and the work it points to is purification.

Is every irritation a sign of our own flaw?

No. Sometimes a person simply wrongs us, and the irritation is accurate. Someone who is rude to a waiter was rude to the waiter, whatever lives in us.

The shadow question is for the irritation that is out of proportion, the one that replays at night, the trait that bothers us more than it seems to bother anyone else. For a real wrong, the right response may be a boundary, a conversation or distance. Looking inward is an addition to that response and leaves it standing.

What should we do when someone irritates us?

We can take one small, private step. Tonight, before sleep, name one thing that irritated us in someone today and ask honestly where it lives in us. The answer may be "nowhere", and that is a fine answer. It may be a small, familiar thing, a flash of the same impatience or the same need to be noticed.

Then we say astaghfirullah, once, slowly. This is our own suggestion, a small way to turn a private discovery straight into a request for forgiveness, so that seeing ourselves clearly ends in mercy.

If looking inward starts a loop of harsh self-judgment, or the memory carries real pain, a counsellor or a trusted imam is the right person to sit with it. Looking at the shadow is meant to be gentle.

Frequently asked questions

What is the shadow self?

It is Carl Jung's name for the traits we disown and keep out of sight. According to the theory, they show up indirectly, often as strong reactions to other people.

Why do certain people irritate us so much?

Sometimes because they wrong us, and sometimes because they show a trait we haven't faced in ourselves. One set of experiments supports the second idea in a specific form, though the evidence is limited and debated.1

Is there a shadow self in Islam?

The Qur'an says the soul was inspired with discernment of both its wickedness and its righteousness (Qur'an 91:8). We borrow Jung's vocabulary only as a lens.

Is every irritation a sign of our own flaw?

No. A real wrong deserves a real response. The shadow question is for the irritation that is out of proportion.

What should we do when someone irritates us?

Before sleep, name the irritation, ask where it lives in us, and say astaghfirullah once, slowly. This is our own suggestion.

Sources

Research and references

  1. Newman LS, Duff KJ, Baumeister RF. (1997). A new look at defensive projection: thought suppression, accessibility, and biased person perception. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 72(5).

  2. Pronin E, Gilovich T, Ross L. (2004). Objectivity in the eye of the beholder: divergent perceptions of bias in self versus others. Psychological Review 111(3).