This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Deciduous trees shed their leaves in autumn as part of how Allah made them. The tree forms a sealing layer at the base of each leaf stem, draws back what it can use from the leaf, and then lets the leaf fall, so the tree can get through winter without the cost of holding every leaf.

The Qur'an points us to the earth coming back to life after its lifelessness (Qur'an 30:50). The bare tree in November is a place to practise noticing that, and the botany adds something we can use in our own lives.

IN SHORT

Autumn shedding is a managed process. The place where a leaf will separate is laid down when the leaf first develops. Before the leaf falls the tree seals the join, so the fall leaves no open wound, and it pulls back a large share of the nitrogen and phosphorus the leaf held. Allah made the tree to let go and so survive the winter.

Two ways through winter: the tree that holds every leaf and pays for it, and the tree that seals each leaf, draws back what it can keep and lets go

The school run takes us past the same maple every morning, and in October it was a loud one: red at the top, gold lower down, a drift of colour on the pavement. Now the pavement is brown and wet, and at the bus stop the branches are nearly bare against a white sky.

It is easy to read that as loss, and a tree in November does look like something has been taken from it. The botany tells a different story about what is happening.

Why do trees let go of their leaves in autumn?

Trees let go of their leaves in autumn to save water and energy through winter. NC State Extension calls leaf shedding a survival strategy to save water and energy during the winter, when frozen soil makes it hard to take up moisture.1 UNH Extension makes a matching point about broadleaf hardwoods, which lose their leaves so they won't freeze when temperatures drop.2

The cue is the shortening day. As days shorten and temperatures fall, chlorophyll production slows and then stops, and the green fades.1 The yellows and oranges that appear were in the leaf all along, and the reds are made in autumn as sugars become trapped in the leaf.1,2 The October colour is the sign that the tree has already begun.

How does a tree drop a leaf without hurting itself?

A tree drops a leaf without hurting itself by building a seal first. At the base of each leaf stem it forms a layer that gradually seals off the leaf from the rest of the tree, so the leaf can drop without leaving an open wound.1

The plant biologists who review this field add a detail worth sitting with. Abscission, the shedding of an organ, happens at abscission zones that are laid down as the organ develops. A signalling network then starts the process when it is time to shed.3

So the place where a leaf will let go is built into the leaf as it develops. The sealing layer, in turn, means the leaf drops without an open wound. Both are part of how Allah made the tree.

The same review notes that shedding leaves in the fall is the most visible display of abscission in nature, and that a signalling network starts the process.3 The review is about recent advances in understanding the mechanism, so much of the fine print belongs to specialists.

What does the tree keep when it lets go?

The tree keeps a great deal of what the leaf was holding. A global meta-analysis of 86 studies, covering ferns, forbs, grasses, conifers and both evergreen and deciduous woody plants, found that plants withdrew about 62% of leaf nitrogen and about 65% of leaf phosphorus on average before leaves were shed.4

Two cautions go with those numbers. They are averages across many plant types and many climates, so any one maple will differ. And the study measured nutrients, which says nothing about what a tree "feels". It does show that the shedding is no simple dump: much of the nitrogen and phosphorus has been drawn back before the leaf goes. The study covers those two nutrients only, and other elements, such as calcium, were resorbed far less on average.4

Put the findings side by side. The place of separation is built in advance, the leaf is sealed, much of its nitrogen is drawn back, and then it is released.

What is the bare branch doing in winter?

A bare branch in winter belongs to a tree that Allah made to shed what it could not afford to carry, and it is still standing. The botany sources here describe winter shedding as a way to save water and energy, and they do not follow the tree into spring.1,2 What follows is our own reflection, set beside the science and not drawn from it.

For anyone who has felt the year take things away, the picture is a gentle one. Some of what leaves us may be set down so that we can get through.

What does the Qur'an say about the earth coming back to life?

The Qur'an speaks about the earth being given life after it was lifeless, and it asks us to look:

THE QUR'AN

"So observe the effects of the mercy of Allāh - how He gives life to the earth after its lifelessness. Indeed, that [same one] will give life to the dead, and He is over all things competent."

The ayah is about the earth and about the One who gives it life. It does not mention leaves, and it does not say that a tree's shedding teaches us anything. The reading in this article, that autumn is worth watching, is our own, and the ayah's own conclusion is about the One who is "over all things competent".

What the ayah does ask is that we observe. A November walk is a fair place to start, and a quiet minute with one tree can turn the year's turning into a moment of remembering Allah.

How can we look at a tree today?

This suggestion is our own, and it takes about a minute.

After praying Asr today, stop in front of one tree for a minute. Notice what it has let go of, whether that is the leaves on the branches, the ones drifting down, or the ones already soft on the ground. Then say subhanAllah. The light is low at that hour, and the branches show against it.

If the day has moved on before we get there, tomorrow after Asr will do. Anyone living where trees stay green can look at any plant dropping a few old leaves, which every plant does.

The prayer comes first. This is a minute added to the day, and it should never come in place of anything obligatory.

Frequently asked questions

Why do trees lose their leaves in autumn?

To save water and energy through winter. NC State Extension describes it as a survival strategy, because frozen soil makes water hard to take up.1 UNH Extension notes that broadleaf hardwoods lose their leaves so they won't freeze.2

How does a tree drop a leaf without a wound?

It forms a layer at the base of the leaf stem that gradually seals the leaf off from the tree.1 Plant biologists note that the zone where the leaf separates is laid down as the leaf develops.3

Does a tree take anything back from a leaf before it falls?

Yes, on average. A meta-analysis of 86 studies found about 62% of leaf nitrogen and about 65% of leaf phosphorus withdrawn across plant types, so a particular tree will differ.4

Is a bare tree dead?

A bare deciduous tree is shedding for the winter, and the extension sources describe that as a way to survive it.1,2 Whether a given tree is alive is a question for an arborist who can examine it.

What does the Qur'an say about the earth coming back to life?

It asks us to observe how Allah gives life to the earth after its lifelessness, and it ends that ayah by saying He is over all things competent (Qur'an 30:50).

Sources

Research and references

  1. NC State Extension, Beaufort County Center. The Science of Fall Color.

  2. UNH Extension. Learn the science behind fall foliage (24 September 2020).

  3. Patharkar OR, Walker JC. (2018). Advances in abscission signaling. Journal of Experimental Botany 69(4), 733-740.

  4. Vergutz L, Manzoni S, Porporato A, et al. (2012). Global resorption efficiencies and concentrations of carbon and nutrients in leaves of terrestrial plants. Ecological Monographs 82(2), 205-220.